Showing posts with label debunking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debunking. Show all posts

July 5 - Happy Birthday, P.T. Barnum

 Posted on July 5, 2021

This is an update of my post published on July 5, 2010:



Born on this day in 1810, Phineas Taylor Barnum grew up to be what some call a great showman—and what others call a shameless huckster.

He opened a circus he billed as “the Greatest Show on Earth,” and he presented what was then called a "freak show," exhibiting such “curiosities” as little people (folks with dwarfism), conjoined twins, albinos, giants, and other non-freaks who happened to have unusual conditions.


Barnum included in his show exhibits like "the Feejee Mermaid," which was supposed to be the mummified body of a mermaid, but was really the torso and head of a baby monkey attached to a large fish tail, and covered with paper maché.


Barnum used “hype” to entertain people – and, with fakes such as the “Feejee Mermaid,” one would say to fool people—but he was honest that his performances were "humbug" (lies or trickery). He was not fond of people using humbug and claiming that it was real, true, and honest!

Barnum felt so strongly about this, he used his knowledge of trickery to debunk people who ripped others off. Mediums claimed to speak to the dead, but, Barnum said, exploited grieving people who would pay almost any amount of money to speak with their loved ones again. Barnum helped to reveal the tricks used...And he even served as an expert witness on "humbuggery" (!) in a trial of William Mumler, who claimed he could take photos of "spirits" - aka dead people. Apparently he proved to all that Mumler was a fraud when he showed a photo of himself with Lincoln - a photo a photographer made without reference to spirits!

(Above) Mumler took a photo of Mary Todd Lincoln, and it
convinced her that her dearly departed husband Abe Lincoln
was still watching over her. 

At the trial, P.T. Barnum presented this photo of himself with
Lincoln supposedly watching over HIM!



Apparently Mumler was acquitted because Barnum's proof didn't rise to legal-level proof that Mumler's spirit photos were fraudulent - but Mumler's spirit-photo business and his reputation  never recovered.

P.T. Barnum Said...

“There's a sucker born every minute.”

And:














October 23 – TV Talk Show Host Day

Posted on October 23, 2014

One of the America's favorite TV talk shows has been The Tonight Show, which has been on as long as I've been alive. (Translation: a loooooong time!) It is the longest currently running regularly scheduled entertainment program in the U.S. and the third longest-running show of any sort on NBC. And it owes a lot of its success to Johnny Carson, who headed the show for THIRTY years!

(Of course, other amazing talents have also headed the show: Steve Allen, Jack Paar, Jay Leno, Conan O'Brien, and now Jimmy Fallon.)

Well, today is Johnny Carson's birthday. And in honor of this most excellent of TV talk show hosts, today has been declared TV Talk Show Host Day!

One of Carson's repeating characters was
a funny "psychic" named Carnak the
Magnificent.
Johnny Carson was so many things, which is why he was such a good host: he was a comedian, writer, actor, musician, and an amateur magician. And he was a skeptic who hated religious fundamentalism and superstition. His background in magic helped him to be aware of the fact that some people who claim to have paranormal abilities are really just doing magic tricks. Magicians remind their audiences that they are creating illusions – but psychics do similar sorts of tricks AND THEN LIE ABOUT IT! Way not cool!


Carson actually helped show up some of these psychics as fakes on his show. 

For example, Carson and magician James Randi showed that Israeli so-called psychic Uri Geller was a fake; Geller was unable to do his famous spoon-bending trick because Carson supplied the spoons. 

Carson and Randi teamed up again to prove that the faith healer Peter Popoff was a charlatan. Carson also helped to support Randi's efforts to debunk junk pseudoscience and promote skepticism by donating to the James Randi Foundation and The Amazing Meetings. 


Carson also helped the field of science by sometimes inviting scientists onto the show. He invited astronomer Carl Sagan onto the show 26 times!

The fact that he helped encourage both skepticism and the popular understanding of science are my two favorite things about Johnny Carson! 

And now that he is gone, I appreciate the efforts of Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert as well. Hooray for comedians as talk show hosts!





Also on this date:
















Plan ahead:

Check out my Pinterest boards for:
And here are my Pinterest boards for: